Essentially, I wanted the kids to help me build a s'more.My original idea involved trying to add all sorts of healthy fruits and veggies to it, in the hopes that I'd get a chorus of "Nooooos!". (Obviously, adding anything resembling broccoli to a s'more would be akin to blasphemy.) Then I realized that a number of my 2s and 3s might not be familiar with a s'more, so I decided to get a lot more obvious with my incorrect ingredients.
I don't think it gets much more obvious than a shoe! (Well, I hope.)
Or a fish!
Mmmmm, a delicious chocolate-marshmallow-shoe-fish s'more! My favorite!
We also have a chef puppet, which I'd debated bringing out so he could promise the kids "ze best s'more in ze world!" (Probably would have had to work on my French accent for that one.) Anyway, that's the general idea! If you try it out, let me know how it goes over, since I didn't get the chance to use it myself!